With The Sins Beneath, director Aaron Christian Paderewski delivers a quietly unsettling horror-thriller that unfolds with the slow tension of a pressure cooker on the verge of exploding.
Known for his previous work on River Rats, The Curse of Cain, and His Name is Greg, Paderewski, along with co-writer Jason Usry, offers an atmospheric tale that borrows from the golden age of horror while injecting it with a modern sense of dread and social unease.
Shot against the moody, moss-draped backdrop of Charleston, South Carolina, the film follows a New York family seeking a fresh start in the country. Darren (Willie Raysor) has purchased a picturesque estate for his wife Marie (Jana Allen), their two daughters Renee (Meagan Lynn) and Sally (Ziona Shaw), and Marie’s mother Brenda (Cindy Hogan). But their arrival at the seemingly tranquil property triggers a chain of increasingly disturbing events. The family is not alone — something ancient and angry lies beneath the surface. As the film’s tagline ominously puts it: “Their lives are about to be judged by the sins beneath.”
Paderewski doesn’t rush his scares. Instead, he cultivates a creeping paranoia — whispering rather than shouting — a style that’s far more effective than the jump-scare-heavy approach of many modern horror films. As the story unfolds, the family is subjected to ghostly visions, creeping mistrust, and supernatural phenomena that hint at a buried past too malevolent to stay hidden.
The cast delivers commendable performances across the board. Willie Raysor is compelling as a father trying to hold everything together, slowly unraveling under pressure. Jana Allen — recognizable from Fear Street and Manhunt: Unabomber — brings a grounded presence to the screen, adding emotional weight to her scenes. Cindy Hogan’s portrayal of the judgmental grandmother Brenda adds a sharp-edged wit, serving as an unsettling voice amid the growing chaos. Ryan King, as the mysterious Pete, brings an uncanny unease to every scene he’s in.
What sets The Sins Beneath apart from other indie horror films is its mood. The cinematography leans into darkness, but never sacrifices clarity. Low light is used with intention, creating a visual palette that is murky, claustrophobic, and loaded with suspense. The ominous black ooze that bubbles from the ground becomes a physical manifestation of the rot festering below the surface — both literal and metaphorical.
One of the film’s more interesting subtexts revolves around racial tension. Darren’s interactions with the community — and even his own mother-in-law — reveal underlying prejudice, never spelled out but always present. These moments of discomfort feel intentionally woven into the supernatural horror, blurring the lines between what is haunting the family spiritually, and what is haunting them socially.
The score, too, is notable — a brooding, atmospheric presence that elevates the tension without overwhelming the scenes. It pulses beneath the action like a second heartbeat, guiding the audience through the foggy uncertainty of who to trust and what to believe.
Watching The Sins Beneath transported me to the feeling I had during my first viewings of 1970s horror classics like The Amityville Horror, Burnt Offerings, and Rosemary’s Baby. There’s a throwback sensibility at play here — a dedication to slow builds, quiet dread, and deeply human fears — which gives the film a vintage horror soul wrapped in modern anxieties.
While not every narrative thread is tied up, and some tropes may feel familiar, The Sins Beneath is undeniably effective in its delivery. It proves that you don’t need a blockbuster budget to craft an evocative, intelligent horror film — just vision, patience, and a willingness to dig into the darkness.
Leave a Reply